She could go for the innocent joke of handholding (it's not like Japanese society was ever particularly keen on any sort of PDA, even something innocuous as that). And it's not untrue; she definitely likes how it feels to be grounded like this.
And on the far end, there are a couple of truly filthy things she could suggest. Some of them are about Maera, which would be doubly (ha) awkward to even insinuate to Mallory.
And then somewhere in between... ]
It, it's true... are you sure you wanna hear this sorta thing?
[It's not too late to back down, he reminds himself. There are probably some things that shouldn't be shared even between best friends. She could unleash something that'll change his entire perspective and it'll be really awkward to have that image in his mind.
But! She's probably bluffing. Even Peony can't be that shameless. Or else she's going to make up something completely crazy. Which he can probably think of a counter to.]
Go ahead. It's my turn to know all your dirty little secrets.
[ Oh boy. Oh boy oh heck oh jeeze. Now is a moment of truth, isn't it? And now that Icarus and Maera are here, even if she doesn't say anything, it's surely going to be obvious before long. Maybe it's already been obvious?? Did Mallory actually figure out what she meant by sharing, or did he think that Icarus was some kind of main character in his own mini harem series?!
Peony takes a deep breath and squeezes Mallory's hand hard. Here goes nothing. ]
A, as it turns out, m--my boyfriend has a boyfriend, and... and he's my other boyfriend, so...
Of course he assumed the harem route. Luna and Icarus could have the entire world if they so chose! And here Mallory was still reeling over the fact that he could be wanted by anyone at all. Let alone two... people...??
So that's why she got so touchy-feely after she came back!
His grip on her hand loosens, but he doesn't really pull away. He's not disgusted or anything, just suddenly terribly uncertain.]
You're- serious? So that's what you meant by sharing...
[He never realized this could be a possibility in any universe. HE... NEEDS A MINUTE HERE...]
[ His grip loosens and her impulse is to yank her hand back. There we go, there's everything ruined again; maybe she should just get up and leave now, before she has to see any kind of rejection in his face.
...on the other hand, she'd (half) promised Maera she'd stop doing that, and at this point, the damage is already done. Mallory knows. He'll take that knowledge with him from hereon, and even if he doesn't like it -- well, Peony's not going to not keep close to people who want her, even if that might make things otherwise awkward. There's surely some kind of compromise in that, right?
She does look away, though. It's not quite running away or avoiding, but she also still doesn't want to look at him when he starts laughing at her. ]
[There are so many questions forming in Mallory's mind that he barely even notices the heavy silence sitting over them. Questions like, is that kind of love triangle even a thing? and did the other me have as much trouble wrapping his head around it?
He falls back onto his back, pursing his lips while he considers it. As stunned as he is by all this mind-blowing revelation (it's been a BIG DAY for his sense of reality), he's still just aware enough to give her hand a reaffirming squeeze, because it probably doesn't look good for him not to launch into an immediate celebration or anything.]
...Huh.
[He clears his throat, his brows furrowing in thought while he stares at nothing in particular.]
Never would have seen that one coming. We were so head over heels for Luna this whole time. [Or Icarus. WHATEVER, she knows what he means.] ...But you are the only woman- hell, the only person at all besides him- I've cared to spend my life with.
[They were all practically married already, weren't they.]
[ Meanwhile, she'd been mentally rehearsing how to appease him -- it's all right, I know it's weird, I don't expect you to want anything, haha it's a moot point anyway isn't it -- so when he says that, the startled noise bursts from her before she can actually bite it back.
For [you], I'd try it with a woman, Maera had said, and now Mallory's saying this, and, ?!?
Nothing about today has been anything Peony had really been prepared for -- not the stupid (cute) birthday terror, not Icarus and Maera showing up, and not Mallory just -- just accepting her confession like that. She feels adrift and bewildered, and it's not panic, but it's not not panic, either. ]
Th... there's a limit to how much I can assume, you know--!
[ She knows that he loves her ("her"?? god what if another her shows up someday? she'll have to murder her and hide the body, which, is that suicide? technically?! ahhhhhh). She's known that for years, and however gruff and snappish he's come off, she's never doubted that. There had been times where she'd used that deliberately to her advantage, during her time as Despair.
But loving someone and loving someone are very different things. Peony herself had to adjust to that, and she'd never had the hurdle of -- well. She knows very well what his preferences are, and on a very fundamental level, she fits absolutely none of them. ]
Y, you know I mean more than just -- like this, right? We've actually, um. We've. You know??
[ YEAH... YEAH, HE GETS IT. He's not that stupid!! Maybe?! He figured that was part of what she meant by dating, but he didn't need her to just confirm it out loud like that! Now he has to actually address it and what the hell is he supposed to say?
He just stares at her helplessly, like, please, realize the situation you've put him in...]
[ Listen, Peony is not prepared to have any kind of romantic anything with Naegi Makoto, that is just weird. ]
I... I don't know.
[ Not that she had any real idea beforehand, and his response is not particularly instilling her with confidence. Does he want anything? He probably doesn't, right?! He's not under any obligation to try.
(She does suspect on some level that Maera would be annoyed at her for thinking about it as obligation, but it's honestly difficult not to, and especially right now.)
Since he let go of her hand, she curls both of her arms closer to herself, peering at him uncertainly. ]
I, I mean... I don't even know what you want. I'm not going anywhere, but we're not -- you don't have to -- I don't even know how any of this even works.
[ Query: is it possible to cheat on your boyfriend with himself?? What would Icarus think?! No agony aunt has ever had to deal with a situation like this!! ]
[He pushes himself up into a sitting position, rubbing at his face again, and then tucks his hair back behind his ear. A weary sigh escapes him as he turns his gaze away.]
...Yeah... I was already worried about how I'm supposed to treat Icarus, now this? It's not like I hate the idea or anything. It's just a lot to think about all at once.
[If Maera's already happy in that arrangement, then surely the potential for Mallory to be down with it is there too, but would there be some kind of competition there to begin with, or-?]
Hah. And here I thought all my romantic problems were finally solved.
Not hating it isn't the same as liking it! Even for you.
[ She rolls onto her back when he sits up, keeping her hands folded close to her chest. It feels like a question asked and answered, but maybe, finally, she is learning to not just take her first impression and run.
For now, anyway.
The automatic thing for her to do is smile at him, lopsided and awkward, trying so hard not to let her own unease show. It's not really successful, but it's the best defense she has. ]
Nothing has to change for us, if you don't want it to.
I get the feeling some kinda change is unavoidable now. I mean in general.
[You know, with the living situation itself. And finally realizing how things are between himself and Luna now. And his decision to try to become a better person overall...
After a beat he reaches over to stroke one of her ears.]
[ She starts briefly at that, then quietly tilts her head to lean into the touch. If he's willing to do that (and initiate! on his own!), she's not going to turn that down. It feels nice -- comforting, though she knows that would probably sound odd to him. ]
Mmm. I think so.
But that doesn't mean -- ah, things are going to be complicated, won't they? I don't wanna make them worse. Especially for you.
I'll have to... ah, unless Icarus does it first. He might.
[ It's not that she would ever characterize him (them?!) as a possessive man, but it might be an entirely different story when it comes to himself. Honestly, if anything, she would believe he'd be more inclined to posture at himself than anyone else. Maera had certainly been concerned about that on his side. ]
I mean, I don't know what Luna thinks about any of this either.
I don't see them not having similar feelings on it...
[Although... Hmm. Even Mal's not sure their given similarity is going to end well. He's never been a guy to settle for taking second place or sharing leadership, and who can tell if that will extend to even feeling competitive with himself.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
She could go for the innocent joke of handholding (it's not like Japanese society was ever particularly keen on any sort of PDA, even something innocuous as that). And it's not untrue; she definitely likes how it feels to be grounded like this.
And on the far end, there are a couple of truly filthy things she could suggest. Some of them are about Maera, which would be doubly (ha) awkward to even insinuate to Mallory.
And then somewhere in between... ]
It, it's true... are you sure you wanna hear this sorta thing?
no subject
But! She's probably bluffing. Even Peony can't be that shameless. Or else she's going to make up something completely crazy. Which he can probably think of a counter to.]
Go ahead. It's my turn to know all your dirty little secrets.
no subject
[ Oh boy. Oh boy oh heck oh jeeze. Now is a moment of truth, isn't it? And now that Icarus and Maera are here, even if she doesn't say anything, it's surely going to be obvious before long. Maybe it's already been obvious?? Did Mallory actually figure out what she meant by sharing, or did he think that Icarus was some kind of main character in his own mini harem series?!
Peony takes a deep breath and squeezes Mallory's hand hard. Here goes nothing. ]
A, as it turns out, m--my boyfriend has a boyfriend, and... and he's my other boyfriend, so...
no subject
wait
Of course he assumed the harem route. Luna and Icarus could have the entire world if they so chose! And here Mallory was still reeling over the fact that he could be wanted by anyone at all. Let alone two... people...??
So that's why she got so touchy-feely after she came back!
His grip on her hand loosens, but he doesn't really pull away. He's not disgusted or anything, just suddenly terribly uncertain.]
You're- serious? So that's what you meant by sharing...
[He never realized this could be a possibility in any universe. HE... NEEDS A MINUTE HERE...]
no subject
...on the other hand, she'd (half) promised Maera she'd stop doing that, and at this point, the damage is already done. Mallory knows. He'll take that knowledge with him from hereon, and even if he doesn't like it -- well, Peony's not going to not keep close to people who want her, even if that might make things otherwise awkward. There's surely some kind of compromise in that, right?
She does look away, though. It's not quite running away or avoiding, but she also still doesn't want to look at him when he starts laughing at her. ]
no subject
He falls back onto his back, pursing his lips while he considers it. As stunned as he is by all this mind-blowing revelation (it's been a BIG DAY for his sense of reality), he's still just aware enough to give her hand a reaffirming squeeze, because it probably doesn't look good for him not to launch into an immediate celebration or anything.]
...Huh.
[He clears his throat, his brows furrowing in thought while he stares at nothing in particular.]
Never would have seen that one coming. We were so head over heels for Luna this whole time. [Or Icarus. WHATEVER, she knows what he means.] ...But you are the only woman- hell, the only person at all besides him- I've cared to spend my life with.
[They were all practically married already, weren't they.]
Just... never expected that...
no subject
[ Meanwhile, she'd been mentally rehearsing how to appease him -- it's all right, I know it's weird, I don't expect you to want anything, haha it's a moot point anyway isn't it -- so when he says that, the startled noise bursts from her before she can actually bite it back.
For [you], I'd try it with a woman, Maera had said, and now Mallory's saying this, and, ?!?
Nothing about today has been anything Peony had really been prepared for -- not the stupid (cute) birthday terror, not Icarus and Maera showing up, and not Mallory just -- just accepting her confession like that. She feels adrift and bewildered, and it's not panic, but it's not not panic, either. ]
I, oh. Y-- you're not mad...?
no subject
[Now it's his turn to utter his bafflement. He turns his face toward her again, narrowing his eyes.]
What the hell would I be mad about? Surprised, sure, but it's not like I'm going to banish you for- what, liking me? Dog me?
[. . .Suddenly, in saying that, he feels INCREDIBLY STUPID for the fears he held on to for so many years about his own affections. Oh. Oh. Oh...
He does let go now, because he desperately needs a hand to run down his face.]
Come on. I feel the same way he does about you, obviously. [Right?? He just never considered the whole romantic aspect.]
no subject
[ She knows that he loves her ("her"?? god what if another her shows up someday? she'll have to murder her and hide the body, which, is that suicide? technically?! ahhhhhh). She's known that for years, and however gruff and snappish he's come off, she's never doubted that. There had been times where she'd used that deliberately to her advantage, during her time as Despair.
But loving someone and loving someone are very different things. Peony herself had to adjust to that, and she'd never had the hurdle of -- well. She knows very well what his preferences are, and on a very fundamental level, she fits absolutely none of them. ]
Y, you know I mean more than just -- like this, right? We've actually, um. We've. You know??
[ PLEASE ACTUALLY GET IT...! ]
no subject
He just stares at her helplessly, like, please, realize the situation you've put him in...]
Was I good?
no subject
Yyyy-- yes?! Yes, if that's the part you were worried about!!
no subject
This must be Naegi's fault, somehow!]Oh... great.
[AHEM.]
So, ...where... does that put us? You and me-me.
[He still has no idea how to feel about any of this, or if she's expecting anything from him now, or... what...]
no subject
I... I don't know.
[ Not that she had any real idea beforehand, and his response is not particularly instilling her with confidence. Does he want anything? He probably doesn't, right?! He's not under any obligation to try.
(She does suspect on some level that Maera would be annoyed at her for thinking about it as obligation, but it's honestly difficult not to, and especially right now.)
Since he let go of her hand, she curls both of her arms closer to herself, peering at him uncertainly. ]
I, I mean... I don't even know what you want. I'm not going anywhere, but we're not -- you don't have to -- I don't even know how any of this even works.
[ Query: is it possible to cheat on your boyfriend with himself?? What would Icarus think?! No agony aunt has ever had to deal with a situation like this!! ]
no subject
...Yeah... I was already worried about how I'm supposed to treat Icarus, now this? It's not like I hate the idea or anything. It's just a lot to think about all at once.
[If Maera's already happy in that arrangement, then surely the potential for Mallory to be down with it is there too, but would there be some kind of competition there to begin with, or-?]
Hah. And here I thought all my romantic problems were finally solved.
no subject
[ She rolls onto her back when he sits up, keeping her hands folded close to her chest. It feels like a question asked and answered, but maybe, finally, she is learning to not just take her first impression and run.
For now, anyway.
The automatic thing for her to do is smile at him, lopsided and awkward, trying so hard not to let her own unease show. It's not really successful, but it's the best defense she has. ]
Nothing has to change for us, if you don't want it to.
no subject
[You know, with the living situation itself. And finally realizing how things are between himself and Luna now. And his decision to try to become a better person overall...
After a beat he reaches over to stroke one of her ears.]
But that's better than living in the past, right?
no subject
Mmm. I think so.
But that doesn't mean -- ah, things are going to be complicated, won't they? I don't wanna make them worse. Especially for you.
no subject
[Come on, his life's been one big clusterfuck since he got here. Before that, even.]
...You gonna break this to Luna too?
[HE'S... PROBABLY GOING TO FIND OUT ONE WAY OR ANOTHER...]
no subject
[ It's not that she would ever characterize him (them?!) as a possessive man, but it might be an entirely different story when it comes to himself. Honestly, if anything, she would believe he'd be more inclined to posture at himself than anyone else. Maera had certainly been concerned about that on his side. ]
I mean, I don't know what Luna thinks about any of this either.
no subject
[Although... Hmm. Even Mal's not sure their given similarity is going to end well. He's never been a guy to settle for taking second place or sharing leadership, and who can tell if that will extend to even feeling competitive with himself.
Hoo, boy.]
no subject
Okay, a lot worried. ]
...Either the only person he's going to be willing to yield to is himself, or he's the last person he'd listen to.
no subject
no subject
no subject
[Any other deathmatch, sure, there's no question. But this is ridiculous.]
no subject
[ COME ON NOW, BRO, YOU KNOW SHE'S NOT GOING TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT EITHER!! ]
W, we just, we can't leave them alone with any sort of sharp objects...
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)